Spring 2025 Brooklyn Real Estate Market Update: Recent Trends and What’s Ahead

The first quarter of 2025 showed continued strength in both Brooklyn and Manhattan, despite stock market volatility, political uncertainty and the ripple effects of ongoing tariff tensions. While concerns linger about how the new federal administration will impact the economy, the residential real estate market has remained resilient, posting some of the strongest activity since 2021.

Market Insights

• New Listings: Active listings climbed to 3,406 units, up 2.7% from late March. Sellers responded to early-year momentum with increased inventory, expanding buyer options and energizing the spring market
• Contracts & Closings: Q1 2025 contracts signed rose 7% year-over-year to 966, signaling renewed buyer interest and confidence. However, closings declined 8% YOY and 3% quarter-over-quarter to 1,122, marking a second straight quarter of lower annual sales
• Inventory Levels: Q1 inventory rose 12% YOY—the fourth consecutive annual increase, a trend not seen since 2021. Still, inventory remains 17% below the 10-year Q1 average, underscoring historically tight supply
• Pending Sales: Reached 1,945 contracts by late April—up 1.3% week-over-week and more than 10% YOY from early Q1
• Consumer Sentiment: Jumped from +90 to +112, the highest level in months, tracking with the surge in signed contracts

Demand for Turnkey Homes Across Brooklyn

A major shift this spring is the rising cost and complexity of renovations. Move-in-ready homes are commanding significant premiums, particularly in neighborhoods like Park Slope, Carroll Gardens and Fort Greene, where buyers are fiercely competing for turnkey properties. In contrast, unrenovated homes — even those with strong potential — often require meaningful discounts, creating opportunities for buyers willing to take on a project.

Helping Sellers Make the Right Upgrades

We work closely with our seller clients to navigate this shift, offering strategic advice on pre-sale improvements. In many cases, we recommend targeted renovations and key cosmetic upgrades that can deliver outsized returns, often yielding at least 1.5x on the investment. We also oversee the process from start to finish, connecting clients with vetted contractors, managing timelines and ensuring the final product aligns with buyer expectations. In a market that rewards turnkey homes, this proactive approach can make a meaningful difference in both speed and sale price.

Slight Inventory Uptick Expected

Despite economic headwinds, demand for homes in Brooklyn’s established neighborhoods remains strong. Buyers continue to seek the relative stability of real estate as other asset classes face greater volatility.
Although inventory dropped 8–10% in 2024 compared to the prior year, early signs suggest a slight uptick in available properties this spring. New development condos, particularly in the luxury segment, are attracting renewed attention, but move-in-ready resale homes remain the most competitive segment in both Brooklyn and Manhattan.

Market Finds Its Footing Amid Economic Signals

Mortgage rates, while still higher than historic lows, have stabilized after peaking in late 2024. The Federal Reserve has hinted at potential rate cuts later this year, creating a more predictable environment for buyers. Strong Wall Street bonuses — particularly in finance — are also boosting buyer confidence and fueling demand for high-end properties in both boroughs. Two years of solid stock market gains before the recent dip have supported the purchasing power of well-qualified buyers.

Buyers: Act Quickly or Miss Out

In Brooklyn, the market is expected to remain fast-moving, particularly for move-in ready homes. Buyers should be prepared to act quickly when the right listing hits the market, as bidding wars and multiple-offer scenarios are still common for the best properties.

Competitive Rentals and New Laws Shape the Market

Brooklyn’s rental market remains highly competitive, especially in neighborhoods like Park Slope and Carroll Gardens, where listings often disappear within 24 to 48 hours. Rising rents and limited availability have driven many would-be renters to enter the buying market, further fueling demand.

Additionally, new rental law changes in New York — aimed at strengthening tenant protections and capping certain rent increases — could tighten the rental market even further. Landlords may become more selective with tenants or opt to sell rather than rent, reducing available rental inventory and pushing more pressure onto the for-sale market.

Maximize Your Investment with Our Brooklyn Expertise

Whether you’re looking to buy, sell or rent in Park Slope, Prospect Heights, Prospect Lefferts Gardens, Windsor Terrace or nearby neighborhoods, our real estate team is here to help you make the most of your investment, discover the right home and navigate Brooklyn’s one-of-a-kind market with confidence.

• 7 Repairs to Consider Before Selling Your Brooklyn Home
• Holiday Decorating Tips for Small Spaces
• 9 Questions for First-Time Brooklyn Home Sellers
• Things You Frequently Forget to Clean and How to Clean Them
• 10 Fantastic Women-Run Restaurants in Brooklyn
• 9 Ways to Learn About NYC Black History Year-Round