Garfield Realty » Paul Paglia

Paul Paglia

Co-Owner and Managing Broker of Garfield Realty
Found 96 New Homes for Brooklynites Last Year
Best Hidden Gem to Take the Kids: Puppetworks

Whether you’re looking to sell, purchase or rent, Garfield Realty co-owner Paul Paglia’s goal is to provide you with seasoned guidance so you can make the most informed decision. His unique combination of integrity, expertise and the proven ability to finesse even the most complicated transactions is the reason why the majority of Paul’s business is either repeat or referral based. As a decade long resident of Park Slope, Paul can often be found with his wife, Erin, and sons, Everett and Gus, enjoying the many playgrounds, coffee shops, restaurants and shops our favorite Brooklyn neighborhood has to offer.

Favorite Brooklyn Spot: Prospect Park

I’ve lived in Brooklyn for years now. I’ve seen it change, I’ve seen it grow, and I’ve changed and grown right along with it. What I love most is how the moment you walk out your door the options are endless, from training for the Brooklyn Half in Prospect Park, to strolling through the Botanic Gardens or the Brooklyn Museum, to touring Cacao Prieto in Red Hook or teaching my son to ice skate at Lakeside… Brooklyn is my home and I love it.

Favorite Park Slope Restaurant: Fonda

Hands down the best guacamole in the neighborhood. My wife and I love to come here on date nights in the summertime and sit in the back garden to enjoy some of the best Mexican food around.

Favorite Place in Prospect Park: The Arbors

I proposed to my wife in this very spot. It’s tranquil and beautiful, and the perfect place to enjoy a romantic moment.

Favorite Sandwich Shop: Brancaccio's Food Shop

For a quick bite in Windsor Terrace, nothing beats Brancaccio's. They offer an extensive list of sandwiches and prepared foods to go. Whatever you choose, you can't go wrong.

As first-time home buyers (actually, now: owners!), Paul couldn't have been more patient and knowledgeable. His advice and expertise was invaluable. I truly don't know that we would have gotten the great apartment we did without his help. Yeah, Garfield is smaller than other companies, but because of this, I felt we were given much more attention.

– David B., Clinton Hill

We just rented an awesome house thanks to these guys. Paul Paglia is a rare find in the real estate world. Not pushy, available, responsive and just super nice. A true pleasure to work with and an easy and extremely well organized lease signing process. Wish all realtors were like this.

– Frederico E., Brooklyn

Recently Paul Paglia helped me to get an apartment and I was very, very impressed by his work. He is truly a top class professional and genuinely amiable person. I was looking for a "rare gem" and he found it for me! From the beginning to the final signing he was remarkably responsive, honest, and worked diligently to ensure that the paper work was handled on time and with great attention to detail.

– Nee O., Brooklyn

Paul has helped us rent our apartment 3 times over the years. He is wonderful to work with. He is friendly and personable and takes the time to get to know his clients and we trust his advice. When it eventually comes time to sell our apartment he is the only broker we would even consider.

– Sandy C., Park Slope

My wife and I recently worked with Paul and had a wonderful experience! Anyone that has ever apartment searched in NYC knows how competitive it can be and how pushy some brokers can be as well. Paul was very professional, likable and easy to work with. He has a strong knowledge of the properties he represents in Park Slope. If you are looking to move to this neighborhood, I highly recommend working with Garfield Realty!

– Mike C., Brooklyn

My Listings

149 Prospect Park Southwest

3 Bedroom w/ HO, 3.5 Bath

Past Listings

709 Carroll St

$8,245,000 – 2 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

506 First Street

$4,400,000 – 6+ Bed/3 Bath

37 Montgomery Pl

$4,257,000 – 5 Bed/3 Bath

288 6th Avenue

$3,750,000 – Building/3.5 Bath

540 Eighth Street

$3,175,000 – 5 Bed/2.5 Bath

572 10th Street

$2,800,000 – 5 Bed/3.5 Bath

265 6th Avenue

$2,510,000 – 6+ Bed/2 Bath

385 7th Street

$2,500,000 – 5 Bed/2 Bath

163 Windsor Place

$2,400,000 – 3 Bed w/ HO/2.5 Bath

394 6th Street

$2,225,000 – 6+ Bed/2 Bath

484 11th Street

$2,050,000 – Building/2 Bath

258 Ovington Avenue

$1,815,000 – 6+ Bed/3 Bath

359 7th Street

$1,625,000 – 2 Bed/1.5 Bath

20 Plaza Street East

$1,300,000 – 2 Bed/1.5 Bath

340 11th Street

$1,300,000 – 3 Bed/1.5 Bath

348 12th St

$1,300,000 – 3 Bed w/ HO/1.5 Bath

359 7th Street

$1,295,000 – 2 Bed/2 Bath

340 11th Street

$1,265,000 – 3 Bed/1.5 Bath

359 7th Street

$1,265,000 – 2 Bed/2 Bath

359 7th Street

$1,225,000 – 2 Bed/2 Bath

541 8th Street

$1,200,000 – 4 Bed/1 Bath

379 1st Street

$1,125,000 – 2 Bed/1.5 Bath

1492 Bedford Avenue

$1,100,000 – 3 Bed/2 Bath

380 E. 35th Street

$1,100,000 – 5 Bed/5.5 Bath

305 Eighth Avenue

$1,060,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

1492 Bedford Avenue

$1,015,000 – 3 Bed/1.5 Bath

1496 Bedford Avenue

$1,010,000 – 3 Bed/1.5 Bath

535 Dean Street

$999,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

230 Park Place

$975,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

20 Plaza Street East

$950,000 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

75 Prospect Park Southwest

$950,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

221 Eight Ave

$950,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

20 Plaza Street East

$942,500 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

423 15th Street

$940,000 – 3 Bed/1 Bath

707 Carroll Street

$850,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

279 1st St

$845,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

303 Beverley Road

$841,000 – 2 Bed/2 Bath

175 PROSPECT PARK

$835,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

1209 8th Ave.

$816,750 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

279 Prospect Pl

$815,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

20 Plaza Street East

$810,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

235 Lincoln Place

$809,200 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

20 Plaza Street East

$800,000 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

135 Ocean Parkway

$785,000 – 2 Bed/2 Bath

723 President Street

$753,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

175 PROSPECT PARK

$750,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

483 12th Street

$750,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

14 Prospect Park Sw

$750,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

20 Plaza Street East

$743,000 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

343 4th Avenue

$735,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

7 Prospect Park Southwest

$735,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

81 Ocean Parkway

$730,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

303 Beverley Road

$725,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

786 Washington Ave

$725,000 – Flex 2/1.5 Bath

483 12th Street

$725,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

81 Ocean Parkway

$715,000 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

303 Beverley Road

$700,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

916 Union St

$690,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

7 Prospect Park Southwest

$680,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

202 Seeley St

$675,000 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

303 Beverley Road

$675,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

115 Eastern Parkway

$668,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

75 Prospect Park Southwest

$650,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

227 Ocean Pkwy

$615,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

227 Ocean Pkwy

$607,500 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

75 Prospect Park Southwest

$600,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

185 Prospect Park Southwest

$597,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

390 14th Street

$580,000 – 1 Bed/1.5 Bath

115 Eastern Parkway

$560,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

415 Avenue C

$535,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

135 Prospect Park SW

$499,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

100 Ocean Pkwy

$485,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

135 Prospect Park SW

$475,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

135 Prospect Park West

$455,000 – Jr 1 Bed/1 Bath

195 Garfield Place

$395,000 – Studio/1 Bath

130 8th Avenue

$390,000 – Studio/1 Bath

195 Garfield Place

$383,000 – Studio/1 Bath

20 Plaza Street East

$363,000 – Studio/1 Bath

75 Prospect Park Southwest

$350,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$255,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$255,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$255,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$255,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$245,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$245,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$245,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$235,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$220,500 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$215,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$215,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$200,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$195,000 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$187,500 – Studio/1 Bath

37 Montgomery Pl

$12,500 – 4 Bed/2.5 Bath

212 Garfield Place

$11,000 – 6+ Bed/2.5 Bath

343 6th Street

$11,000 – 5 Bed/3.5 Bath

857 President Street

$7,200 – 3 Bed/2.5 Bath

857 President Street

$7,000 – 3 Bed/2.5 Bath

348 6th Avenue

$6,300 – 3 Bed/2 Bath

245 Garfield Place

$5,800 – 2 Bed/2 Bath

442 8TH ST

$5,500 – 2 Bed/2 Bath

81 Ocean Parkway

$5,500 – 3 Bed/3 Bath

81 Ocean Parkway

$5,500 – 3 Bed/3 Bath

391 Dean Street

$5,500 – 3 Bed/2 Bath

409 3rd St

$5,400 – Flex 3/2 Bath

391 Dean Street

$5,100 – 3 Bed/2 Bath

81 Ocean Parkway

$5,000 – 3 Bed/3 Bath

315 Garfield Place

$4,995 – 1 Bed/2 Bath

390A 6th Avenue

$4,950 – 2 Bed/1.5 Bath

390A 6th Avenue

$4,950 – 2 Bed/1.5 Bath

390A 6th Avenue

$4,950 – 2 Bed/1.5 Bath

153 7th Avenue

$4,900 – 4 Bed/2 Bath

153 7th Avenue

$4,900 – 4 Bed/2 Bath

378 Atlantic Avenue

$4,800 – 3 Bed/2 Bath

153 7th Avenue

$4,800 – 4 Bed/2 Bath

365 Dean Street

$4,600 – 3 Bed/2 Bath

81 Ocean Parkway

$4,500 – 3 Bed/3 Bath

564 1st Street

$4,500 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

305 Eighth Avenue

$4,400 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

365 Dean Street

$4,350 – 3 Bed/2 Bath

365 Dean Street

$4,350 – 3 Bed/2 Bath

352 4th Street

$4,300 – 2 Bed w/ HO/1.5 Bath

428 3rd Street

$4,300 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

352 4th Street

$4,250 – 2 Bed w/ HO/1.5 Bath

479 11th St

$4,150 – 2 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

428 3rd Street

$4,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

346 6th Avenue

$4,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

745 Union Street

$4,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

346 6th Avenue

$4,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

745 Union Street

$4,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

246 6th Avenue

$3,800 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

427 3rd Street

$3,750 – 2 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

428 3rd Street

$3,700 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

315 Garfield Place

$3,695 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

246 6th Avenue

$3,600 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

256 Garfield Place

$3,600 – Flex 2/1 Bath

745 Union Street

$3,600 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

246 6th Avenue

$3,600 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

442 50th Street

$3,500 – 2 Bed w/ HO/2 Bath

427 3rd Street

$3,500 – 2 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

428 3rd Street

$3,500 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

428 3rd Street

$3,500 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

616 6th Street

$3,400 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

212 Garfield Place

$3,400 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

212 Garfield Place

$3,400 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

745 Union Street

$3,400 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

348 6th Avenue

$3,400 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

350 6th Avenue

$3,400 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

350 6th Avenue

$3,400 – 2 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

616 6th Street

$3,400 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

428 3rd Street

$3,350 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

256 Garfield Place

$3,300 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

212 Garfield Place

$3,300 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

256 Garfield Place

$3,300 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

288 6th Avenue

$3,200 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

442 50th Street

$3,200 – 2 Bed w/ HO/2 Bath

288 6th Avenue

$3,200 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

288 6th Avenue

$3,200 – Flex 2/1 Bath

411 15th Street

$3,100 – 3 Bed/1 Bath

494 1st Street

$3,100 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

245 Garfield Place

$3,100 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

432 8th Street

$3,000 – Loft/1 Bath

245 Garfield Place

$3,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

494 1st Street

$3,000 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

424 8th Street

$2,900 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

524 5th Street

$2,900 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

432 8th Street

$2,900 – Loft/1 Bath

448 7th Avenue

$2,850 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

448 7th Avenue

$2,850 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

610 Prospect Ave

$2,800 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

152 8th Avenue

$2,800 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

152 8th Avenue

$2,800 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

358 PROSPECT PL

$2,800 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

430 Clinton Avenue

$2,800 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

457 5th Street

$2,800 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

448 7th Avenue

$2,750 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

285 Sterling Place

$2,750 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

448 7th Avenue

$2,750 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

601 President Street

$2,700 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

358 PROSPECT PL

$2,650 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

385 7th Street

$2,650 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

333 4th Street

$2,600 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

1633 8TH AVE

$2,600 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

152 8th Avenue

$2,600 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

7 Prospect Park Southwest

$2,500 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

333 4th Street

$2,500 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

448 7th Avenue

$2,500 – 1 Bed w/ HO/1 Bath

136 Macon Street

$2,500 – Studio/1 Bath

152 8th Avenue

$2,500 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

152 8th Avenue

$2,400 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

81 Ocean Parkway

$2,400 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

152 8th Avenue

$2,300 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

333 4th Street

$2,300 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

469 5th Street

$2,300 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

136 Macon Street

$2,300 – 1 Bed/2 Bath

416 Park Place

$2,300 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

136 Macon Street

$2,300 – 1 Bed/2 Bath

442 A 8th Street

$2,300 – Studio/1 Bath

442 A 8th Street

$2,200 – Loft/1 Bath

218 Garfield Place

$2,050 – Jr 1 Bed/1 Bath

371 4th Street

$2,000 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

221 Garfield Place

$2,000 – Studio/1 Bath

130 8th Avenue

$2,000 – Studio/1 Bath

221 Garfield Place

$2,000 – Studio/1.5 Bath

442 50th Street

$2,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$2,000 – Jr 1 Bed/1 Bath

442 50th Street

$2,000 – 2 Bed/1 Bath

130 8th Avenue

$2,000 – Studio/1 Bath

130 8th Avenue

$1,950 – Studio/1 Bath

40 OCEAN PKWY

$1,850 – Alcove Studio/1 Bath

163 19th Street

$1,850 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

130 8th Avenue

$1,850 – Studio/1 Bath

621 2nd Street

$1,850 – Alcove Studio/1 Bath

419 3rd Street

$1,800 – 1 Bed/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,800 – Studio/1 Bath

234 6th Avenue

$1,750 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,750 – Studio/1 Bath

130 8th Avenue

$1,750 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,650 – Studio/1 Bath

255A 19th Street

$1,650 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,650 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,650 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,650 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,600 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,600 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,600 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,600 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,600 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,600 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,575 – Studio/1 Bath

300 8th Avenue

$1,575 – Studio/1 Bath